Brexit and the Route Map: Do all roads lead to Rome?

Brexit and the Route Map?

Do all roads lead to Rome?

Rome

Whatever people think of the merits or demerits of Brexit, if, as seems increasingly likely, we fail to agree on all aspects of a Brexit formula before March 2019 (now just a few months away) how are we supposed to advise clients?

It is the nature of our business that we often get asked about the more esoteric bits of tax practice, such as cross border matters and the impact of double tax.

Here is an example, which we have just looked at as part of researching advice for a client in respect of the Swiss/UK double tax treaty.  Of course, Switzerland is not a member of the EU.  However, Clause 18 (4) of the UK/Swiss Treaty only applies if the individual making the claim is “subject to the legislation of the Home State in accordance with the Agreement on the Free Movement of Persons”.

I appreciate this may only apply to a few people, although it should be noted the Governmental Authorities each thought the issue significant to incorporate specifically into the Treaty.  Anyway, are not individual citizens important?

Additionally, if EU concepts are so ingrained into UK tax procedure as to affect non-EU Treaty countries, surely there must be more issues lurking.

Professional bodies what are your views?

In this context, I commend the Article by Alistair Spencer Clarke in the August 2018 edition of ICAEW Tax Line.  Ownership of Spanish property is not an outlandish thought for many UK citizens, quite apart from many other cross border situations which are now common place in our shrinking world.

Please can we start a debate about how to approach this matter?  Here I am talking about practical reality and proper approaches for Tax Practitioners to ensure they are giving best advice to clients.  Constitutional jurisprudence is for another day!

Brexit and European Tax Law

Here are some interesting questions. Well, I think them interesting anyway!

1. If we ‘do Brexit’, will we persist with VAT?

2. If so, how will it be administered, bearing in mind the current cross-border arrangements?

3. Will the European Court remain supreme, in terms of judicial opinion and interpretation?

4. On direct taxes, will we revert to double tax treaties, rather than the various European Directives?

5. If so, from what date?

6. If we do leave the EU, will the Courts go back to the ‘literal’ approach to interpreting tax legislation, a la Justice Rowlatt, or will it continue to dabble in the ‘purposive’ approach?

7. In the context of the above how would anyone define ‘The Purpose of Parliament’, in terms of (say) the formulae in the Emloyee Security/Benefit rules?

Je ne sais pas?

Opinions, s’il vous plait.

Inheritance Tax Series – Overseas Issues

A series of articles highlighting key areas that affect taxpayers and practitioners involved with inheritance tax and estates and identifying opportunities to mitigate inheritance tax.

Inheritance Tax – Overseas Issues

General Rules

Where a person is UK domiciled their estate will be subject to inheritance tax on their worldwide assets.

Therefore overseas assets such as foreign bank accounts, holiday homes etc. will be subject to inheritance tax in the UK.

Relief is given for foreign liabilities (for example an overseas mortgage) by deducting the amount of the liability from the value of non UK property.  Any excess can then be set off against UK property.

 Foreign Property – Deduction for Expenses

Where the estate includes overseas property, the personal representatives may incur additional expenses in connection with the disposal.

It is possible to claim a deduction for expenses of administering or selling overseas property up to a maximum of 5% of the value of all foreign property in the estate.

Thus, where the estate of a UK domiciled person includes a house in Spain worth £250,000, the personal representatives may claim a deduction for expenses of up to £12,500 (£250,000 x 5%), potentially saving inheritance tax of £5,000 (£12,500 x 40%).

Double Tax Relief

Where an estate is subject to inheritance tax in both the UK and another country on the same assets the estate may be subject to double tax.

The UK has double tax treaties for inheritance tax purposes with the Republic of Ireland, USA, South Africa, France, Netherlands, Sweden, Switzerland, Italy, India and Pakistan.

These double tax treaties set out the taxes that qualify for relief under the agreement, the taxing rights of each country in respect of different types of assets as well as the mechanism for double tax relief where inheritance tax is payable in both countries.

It is important that care is taken to review the appropriate double tax treaty carefully because the personal representatives will need to understand whether relief should be claimed in the UK or abroad.

Where inheritance tax is payable in the UK and a similar tax is payable in a country that does not have a double tax treaty with the UK, double tax credit relief should be available in relation to assets situated in the other country under the unilateral relief provisions.

For these purposes the location of the asset is determined in reference to UK law.

The amount of double tax relief under the unilateral provisions is limited to the lower of (i) the UK inheritance tax, or (ii) the foreign inheritance tax.

In cases where tax is payable in both the UK and another country in relation to an asset that is situated in a third country, or treated as situated in the UK under UK law and the other country under that country’s law, a proportion of the tax may be relieved in the UK.